Deep dish at Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta in West Islip

Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta questions, answered

The questions guests ask us most, with straight answers. Prices are on the menu, directions and parking are on the visit page. Anything missing? Call (631) 661-6246.

Hours and visiting

Where is Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta?

Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta is at 636 Union Blvd Ste 3113, West Islip, NY 11795. It's near St. Francis Hospital - South Bay Cardiovascular and Great South Bay Surgical Associates.

What are your hours?

We're open Mon–Sun 10 AM to 10 PM.

Where can I park?

There's a free parking lot and free street parking.

Do you take reservations?

No, we're walk-in only.

Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible?

Yes. Wheelchair-accessible entrance, restroom, seating and parking.

Can I bring my dog?

No, Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta isn't dog-friendly.

Ordering and delivery

Can I order ahead for pickup?

Yes. Order online at ourlittleitaly.direct-ordering.com and pick it up at the counter.

Do you deliver?

Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta delivers the full menu from 636 Union Blvd Ste 3113 to homes and offices in West Islip, within about 4 miles of the restaurant. There's a $2 delivery fee. Order online at ourlittleitaly.direct-ordering.com or call (631) 661-6246 during our hours (Mon–Sun 10 AM to 10 PM).

What payment do you accept?

We accept credit cards, debit cards and tap to pay.

Food and menu

Do you have gluten-free options?

Yes. The menu lists the Margherita Cauliflower Personal Pie ($16.99), the Cauliflower Personal Pie ($15.99) and the Gluten Free Cheese Pizza ($14.99). Ask us about how it's prepared if you have an allergy.

What should I order the first time?

Start with our signature dishes: the Salad Slice ($7.15), the Grandma Pie (12 slices) ($24.99) and the Neopolitan Personal Pie ($14.99).

How much does a meal cost?

Most dishes on the Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta menu cost $6.05 to $29.99. The menu has 17 sections: Most Ordered, Pies, Personal Pies, Pizza by the Slice, Calzones, Rolls and Pinwheels, Appetizers, Side Orders, Soups, Salads, Heros, Paninis, Wraps, Baked Pasta, Pastas, Entrees, Desserts and Beverages, with every price listed on the menu page.

What is the Salad Slice?

The Salad Slice costs $7.15. It's made with your choice of regular -OR- whole wheat 18' round crust with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions and and shredded mozzarella.

What is the Grandma Pie (12 slices)?

The Grandma Pie (12 slices) costs $24.99. It's made with 16" square thin crust pizza layered with fresh mozzarella, basil and marinara sauce.

What is the Neopolitan Personal Pie?

The Neopolitan Personal Pie costs $14.99. It's made with cripsy thin crust pizza topped with mozzarella cheese. Your choice of regular or whole wheat crust.

What most ordered do you serve?

The Most Ordered section of our menu has Neapolitan Pie ($23), Neopolitan Slice ($3.99), Garlic Knots (12 per order) ($8), Buffalo Chicken Slice ($6.60) and Chicken Parmigiana Hero ($16.99), and 7 more.

What pies do you serve?

The Pies section of our menu has Grandma Pie (12 slices) ($24.99), Margherita Pizza ($29.99), Hot Honey Pepperoni Pie ($29.99), Old Fashioned Pizza ($24.99) and Buffalo Chicken Pizza ($32.95), and 38 more.

What personal pies do you serve?

The Personal Pies section of our menu has Margherita Personal Pie ($15.99), Margherita Cauliflower Personal Pie ($16.99), Neopolitan Personal Pie ($14.99), Cauliflower Personal Pie ($15.99) and Gluten Free Cheese Pizza ($14.99).

What pizza by the slice do you serve?

The Pizza by the Slice section of our menu has Neopolitan Slice ($3.99), Sicilian Slice ($4.40), Salad Slice ($7.15), Mac N Cheese Slice ($6.05) and Hot Honey Pepperoni Slice ($6.05), and 37 more.

What calzones, rolls and pinwheels do you serve?

The Calzones, Rolls and Pinwheels section of our menu has Chicken Roll ($12.05), Pepperoni Roll ($12.05), Buffalo Chicken Roll ($12.05), Broccoli Roll ($12.05) and Eggplant Roll ($12.05), and 8 more.

What appetizers do you serve?

The Appetizers section of our menu has Mozzarella Sticks (6 per order) ($13.05), Fried Calamari ($17.99), Fried Ravioli (8 per serving) ($12.99), Chicken Fingers With Fries (3 per order) ($13.99) and Mussels Marinara ($15.99), and 12 more.

What soups do you serve?

The Soups section of our menu has Chicken Vegetable Soup ($8.99), Lentil Soup ($8.99), Pasta E Fagioli ($8.99), Italian Wedding Soup ($8.99) and Stracciatella ($8.99), and 2 more.

What salads do you serve?

The Salads section of our menu has Caesar Salad (small $10.99 or large $13.99), Greek Salad (small $12.99 or large $15.99), Large Cold Antipasto ($17.99) and Tossed Salad (small $10.99 or large $13.99).

What heros do you serve?

The Heros section of our menu has Chicken Parmigiana Hero ($16.99), Eggplant Parmigiana Hero ($15.35), Shrimp Parmigiana Hero ($17.55), Fried Chicken Club ($16.45) and Potato And Egg Hero ($14.25), and 13 more.

What paninis do you serve?

The Paninis section of our menu has Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Rabe Panini ($13.99) and Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers Panini ($13.99).

What wraps do you serve?

The Wraps section of our menu has Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Rabe Wrap ($13.99), Chicken Caesar Wrap ($13.99), Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers Wrap ($13.99) and Shrimp Caesar Wrap ($14.99).

What baked pasta do you serve?

The Baked Pasta section of our menu has Baked Ravioli ($20.99), Baked Meat Lasagna ($21.99), Baked Cavatelli ($21.99), Baked Ziti De Luca ($21.99) and Baked Stuffed Shells ($20.99), and 1 more.

What pastas do you serve?

The Pastas section of our menu has Alla Vodka ($21.99), Alla Vodka With Grilled Chicken ($24.99), Bolognese ($23.99), Tomato Sauce With 3 Meatballs ($21.99) and Meat Sauce ($21.99), and 21 more.

What entrees do you serve?

The Entrees section of our menu has Chicken Parmigiana Entree ($25.99), Chicken Capri ($25.99), Chicken Francese ($25.99), Shrimp Parmigiana Entree ($26.99) and Veal Parmigina Entree ($26.99), and 28 more.

What desserts do you serve?

The Desserts section of our menu has Lava Cake ($6.58), Tiramisu ($6.58), Ice Cream Pint ($7.65), Tartufo ($6.58) and Pasta Fritas (6) ($3.30), and 5 more.

Still have a question?

Call (631) 661-6246 Email us