Serving West Islip since 2012

Overhead view of pepperoni pizza with a slice served on a plate

Pizza · Pasta · Family

A little piece of Italy, right here in West Islip.

Hand-tossed pies, comforting pasta, and the neighborhood hospitality that keeps Long Island coming back.

Order Now Online Call (631) 661-6246

30+different slices

7 days10am–10pm

Localfamily favorite

New York Pizza◆Homestyle Pasta◆Calzones & Heroes◆Catering

Made withAmoresince 2012

Welcome to Our Little Italy

Big flavor. Small-town heart.

We bring the rich, mouthwatering tastes of traditional Italian cooking to West Islip and our neighboring Long Island communities.

Quality ingredients, time-honored recipes, and warm service are at the center of everything we do. Whether you’re craving a classic pie, a hearty pasta dish, or one of more than 30 specialty slices, there’s always something new to love.

Mangia bene!

Start your order →

From our kitchen

Find your new favorite.

From the classics to creative specialty slices, every order is prepared fresh and made to satisfy.

Freshly prepared Italian specialty from Our Little Italy

Pizza, Your Way

Classic pies, specialty slices, and plenty of choices.

Italian Comforts

Hearty pastas and familiar favorites made with care.

Italian comfort food from Our Little Italy

Heroes & More

Calzones, heroes, and satisfying meals for every appetite.

Explore the menu & order

Made fresh. Served happy.

A feast for the eyes.

A customer favorite from Our Little Italy

Come say ciao

Your neighborhood Italian kitchen.

Find us

636 Union Blvd
West Islip, NY 11795

Get directions ↗

Hours

Monday–Sunday
10:00 am – 10:00 pm

Open 7 days a week

Get in touch

(631) 661-6246 ourlittleitaly2012@gmail.com

Fast service, delivery, and catering available.

Order Now Online